- Aug 26th, '00
Since I get so much traffic on my Diet Coke page (it's the most visited page here), I frequently get emails from the lunatic fringe patiently explaining to me how dangerous Aspartame is. Just so you all know my stand on this issue: My opinion is that these folks are spastic wackos.
For those who don't spend as much time with the Diet Coke subculture as I do, the alarmist's theory (one of them anyway) is that Aspartame (the sweetener in Diet Coke) releases methanol in the body which is then converted to formaldehyde. This then spreads through out the body and causes cancer and other nasty things. What nasty things you might ask? Here's the official wacko list:
headaches, joint pain, spasms, cramps, poor memory, depression, mania, insomnia, dizziness, slurred speech, ringing in ears, sexual problems, nausea, seizures, poor vision, rashes, burning eyes, mouth sores, hair loss, obesity, bloating, racing heart, high blood pressure, erratic blood sugar levels, birth defects, and brain cancers.
I actually trimmed the list a bit to eliminate redundancies. Apparently drinking Diet Coke causes most of the bad things that might happen to a person. Worse than tobacco. Worse than alcohol.
According to these loons, if you drink Diet Coke you will eventually be reduced to a twitching, nauseous, impotant, basket case. Then you'll die of brain cancer.
Gee.... Aspartame's been around for a long time (30 years). Why aren't we all dropping dead? BECAUSE IT'S BULLSHIT YOU LOSERS!!!! I just love the way these wackos latch on to a piece of evidence and then run with it, leaving context, other evidence, and all common sense behind.
A cup of tomato juice provides about six times more methanol than a cup of an aspartame sweetened soft drink. So if you drink four cans of soda a day you get the same amount.
The typical response to this is that some people drink several liters of soda everyday. We must save these people! These poor people who are consuming toxic levels of soda pop.
According to the FDA you would have to drink between about 240 to 600 liters (about 675 to 1,690 cans) of an aspartame-sweetened soft drink at one sitting to reach the toxic level. So, as a safety measure, try to limit yourself to 200 or 300 cans a day alright?
So on the one side we have the FDA, the American Medical Association, the American Diabetes Association and the American Dietetic Association, all saying that Aspartame is safe. On the other side we have some loons in need of attention. Hmmm.... Who do I trust. Hmmm.... pass the Diet Coke. In fact pass me 20 liters of Diet Coke, I'm a bit thirsty.
246 Comments
Comments:
As a side note, I can't believe all the BS that goes around on e-mail and how gullible people can be sometimes. Amazing!
When you run the numbers they always fall back on the "if I only save one life it's worth it" speech. When you point out that the same reasoning would lead to banning cows milk they accuse me of exaggerating.
I guess some people just need a crusade.
If you only hear one side of the argument it sounds rather scary. Try to look at both sides of the issue. Then make up your own mind. We have many fringe elements who are pulling information from various studies and formulating their theories. But what about organizations whose sole purpose is to study things like this?. Folks like:
The FDA
American Dietetic Association
Centers for Disease Control
International Food Information Council Foundation
American Diabetes Association
These groups have seen all the research and they say Aspartame is safe.
The fact is that people have been drinking and eating Aspartame for 30 years. With all the things that have been proven to cause health problems, why are people fixating on something that has been proven *not* to? keep in mind that ANYONE can put up a webpage about the health dangers of ANYTHING. Why would you trust these pages? Where does their authority come from? Who oversees their conclusions? I certainly don't trust them.
No, I have no relationship with the soft drink or sweetener industry. I'm a web programmer in San Diego.
I think the phosphoric acid and carbonation would probably also cause problems. [shrug] Beats me. Let me know how it turns out.
"Carefully controlled clinical studies show that aspartame is not an allergen. However, certain people with the genetic disease phenylketonuria (PKU), those with advanced liver disease, and pregnant women with hyperphenylalanine (high levels of phenylalanine in blood) have a problem with aspartame because they do not effectively metabolize the amino acid phenylalanine, one of aspartame's components." However PKU is rare, and you would also have the same symptoms from foods such as meat, fish, poultry, cheese, eggs and cakes and bread made with ordinary flour.
I don't care if you think you're right or not, because I know you're not. But anyway, consuming excessive daily amounts of Aspartame over more than one year causes your body to become addicted (see statement above). It DOES cause cancer and other adverse affects once it accumulates in your body enough. This is the blunt truth. You can accept it or not.
you haven't persuaded anyone that aspartame is safe. if anything, i am reaffirmed in my belief that the majority opinion should always undergo scrutiny. i am with the wackos all the way.
well, seriously mate, i'll drink to your sanity and reasoning, and your researching skills, but i'll have a nice cup of tea and YOU take the foul-tasting, expensive, cumulative poison. i am not a fanatic, i just avoid it. period. bye now!
....He did the studies on aspartic acid, 40% of aspartame and found it caused lesions in the brains of mice. He attempted to stop the approval of aspartame but the pharmaceutical industry was too powerful. Even when the FDA wanted Searle indicted for fraud both U.S. Prosecutors hired on with the defense team and the statute of limitations expired.............
http://www.wnho.net/olneyletter.htm
Click for Documentation
PRODUCTS AND ARTIFICIAL SWEETENING AGENTS
NutraSweet ~ Equal ~ "Sugar Free" ~ Neotame
By James Bowen, M.D. and
Arthur M. Evangelista, former FDA Investigator
(c) 06 May 2002
http://www.wnho.net/aspartame_brain_damage.htm
headaches, spasms, depression, mania, by not drinking enough diet coke.
insomnia, dizziness, by drinking too much diet coke (or it could be the caffien(?))
joint pain, by drinking diet coke too fast and developing tennis elbow from the 12 oz curls
cramps, poor memory, slurred speech, ringing in ears, sexual problems, nausea, poor vision by drink diet coke mixed with strong spirits (rum, whisky the occassional ghost)
rashes from drinking diet coke with strong spirits and NOT developing sexual problems (see your doctor for some penicillin)
burning eyes, mouth sores,
seizures, hair loss, not enough diet coke being consumed
bloating, racing heart, high blood pressure, by drinking diet coke while eating pizza and or pickled eggs
birth defects by believing diet coke cause problems
Too late??? Aspartame has been on the market for 30 years. If the "truth" that Aspartame detractors want to sell us hasn't been established in 30 years, then maybe it's not the truth. 30 years and no peer reviewed studies that can show Aspartame to even be as dangerous as peanuts or milk. Caution is a good thing until it turns into irrationality.
Too late???
Have a look at cigarettes they've also been around for countless years and its only now that people are starting to acknowledge the fact that they might just be harmful. If you however ask the tobacco companies I'm sure they'll tell you that there is no established connection between lung cancer and smoking and yes for those who have already died it is too late. Just because certain groups have the audacity to question the respectability of certain scientific studies the truth takes much longer to surface. Though I guess for most people living in ignorance is a lot easier.
2004-04-07 | SACRAMENTO, California: Lawsuits were filed in three separate California courts against twelve companies who either produce or use the artificial sweetener aspartame as a sugar substitute in their products. The suits were filed in Shasta, Sonoma and Butte County, California, yesterday........
http://www.unobserver.com/layout5.php?id=1563&blz=1
NutraSweet Is Politically Sour...
In a breaking story, The Louisiana Weekly has learned that a class-action lawsuit has been filed against some of America's leading corporations for using the artificial sweetener aspartame despite knowing that it had neurotoxic effects on human beings......
http://www.louisianaweekly.com/cgi-bin/weekly/news/articlegate.pl?20040510q
Pepsi, Coke in the dock again — And this time it's Aspartame
Pratap Ravindran
Pune , April 30
COCA-COLA, PepsiCo and a whole bunch of other big companies are in the dock again, this time around because of their use of the artificial sweetener, aspartame........
http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/2004/05/01/stories/2004050101040400.htm
http://www.eatright.org/Public/NutritionInformation/92_16121.cfm
I really think it's important to have that link because it nails it for me. The American Dietetic Association has no bias or beef with anyone, and they say that Aspartame is as safe as any other natural food you eat. Sure a 1 gram packet of Equal has approx .1 grams of methanol in it, and people typically use 1 or 2 in every glass of tea, if they use it (and approximately the same in a diet soda). Sure methanol turns into formaldehyde, and formaldehyde is bad for you. But methanol is a naturally occurring compound! Do some research, and you'll se it's in a lot of things we eat, and in greater concentration. If you quit drinking Diet Coke because it contains methanol, then quit eating tomatoes, carrots, beef, chicken, fish, wheat etc., because it's there as well.
Right. Well, good luck with that.
I've been posting this info for the last six years. In that time nothing has changed. The anti-aspartame wackos keep saying the exact same thing. Studies still fail to link Aspartame to anything bad. And the flood of Aspartame related problems fail to materialize.
Hundreds of millions of people consume Aspartame every day. They're fine. They have been fine. They'll continue to be fine. Get over it.
I had migraines. I used to drink Diet Coke just about every day. I've been doing so since I was a kid. I quit a year ago. I have had exactly two migraines this year (as opposed to my usual one or two a month). I got one after drinking a diet Coke that a student gave me (with lime! whoopie!). I got the other after eating a piece of chocolate from France that was sweetened with asparatame.
If you are sensitive to it, it's dangerous.
One final comment: aspartame is on the market because monsanto paid for it to be there. More than 75% of the FDA's complaints come from aspartame-sweetened product.
You are free to be a bonehead. It's a free country. But I'll bet you a bazillion dollars that half of the headaches of America would disappear if the folks would get off the crap soda, which leeches calcium out of your bones anyway.
Interesting theory. But unfortunately there is no increase in headaches which coincides with the increase in Aspartame use.
So, once again, if Aspartame causes headaches why aren't we seeing a massive increase in the rate of headaches? Once again you just want to trot out some tired conspiracy theories and anecdotal stories.
So first it was brain cancer, now were down to headaches, and still no numbers to back it up.
Well... anyway, about the guy right up there, if you had migraines, caffeine is not the advisable thing to have in your drinks, if for some reason you had to stop drinking it for a while the first symptom of its abstinence syndrome it's headaches.
Open your eyes you turd.
Oooh noooo!!! Everytime I drink Coke I'm drinking AMERICAN CORPORATE POISON!!!
Go to hell you facking socialist.
(This coming from someone from a Communist country)
Thanks
You're great at manipulating people. Have you really done a study on Aspartame? I don't think you have, at least not a good study on it. And plus, your drinking Diet Coke, have you ever tried to get off it? I'm sure you get symptoms from drinking Diet Coke. You know you do. Your aggressive, which is a diffinate sign of aspartame in your system. I have done my own research on Aspartame, I looked at what the FDA wrote about it, its not convincing enough for me, and you can't trust the FDA. I don't think you will ever know what Diet Coke - Aspartame, can do to you. Actually You DO know, you just keep telling yourself that its OK to drink it. Good Luck with that! And you call yourself smarter than most people?! UGH! You know,I guess that the people that try to get other people off Diet Coke are "Wakos", because they try and save your stupid butts. Think for once.
Oh, and to the next person after me that posts I either need help, or a life, AA, or all three, or I should try and be serious, I say, haahh, you're an incredible stater of the obvious. See the "do everything in moderation" group of people, they are your kind.
Peace to all and enjoy all the fun of life, like sex, rock n roll, and lime diet coke!
BP
I think your sick. What are you thinking? Yeah right your all about getting stuff done.? I think you've lost too many brain cells, Big. Why don't you just drink water? Its much tastier than lime diet coke and rum, (nasty). Well I'm glad your living the simple life, no care in the world. God get a life.
eVeryone knows in their heart &&& gut that Diet COKE is artificial crap ... why be Artificial CRAP ...
eat Whole FOOD as close to the source as possible - this is hard eNUFF without ADDING further insult to Ur body in the FORM of DCoke
Ooh! This just reminded me, one of Sainsbury(UK Supermarket)'s shower gels has formaldehyde in it(yes, really, it's listed in the ingredients), interesting eh? Maybe that's just me then.
I really have no idea where my hairy nipples came from or how the webbing formed between my toes, but I chalk that up to years of watching too many Starsky & Hutch *twitch* re-runs.
..the Softdrinks Industry has a huge lobby (and LOTS of cash! .. correction LOTS AND LOTS AND LOTS of CASH!!!)
Don't believe everything the FDA says... as they are probably on the industrie's Payrole one way or another! ..and the Pharma Industry actually WANTS sick people to buy their medications. Hell.. if they can convince the public that Marijuhana is bad for you soft drinks (where you usuallay don't exactly KNOW what you are consuming) should be a doddle. ;)
If things that were bad for you were illegal.. don't you think McD' (watch "Supersize Me!") would be illegal? Not to mention tobacco and alcohol...
I pity you for your extremely naive perspective!
If drinking diet cola is causing you problems, stop drinking it. If it's not causing you problems, drink it. One day we may figure out(asbestos is a good example) that constant exposure causes problems or cancer but we're not there yet.
I'd also be interested to know how many of you who "would never drink aspartame", smoke, drink or do drugs instead. All of those things are ACTUALLY proven to be bad for you. How can you expect anyone to take your comments about potential "poison" seriously if you continue to kill yourself with actual poisons?
as for the devotees:
as-par-ta-me = "its part of me"
The research in this report, that you mentioned in a comment, was paid for by the producer of aspartame.
Here's a quote at the end of that page:
[quote]The study was conducted at MIT's CRC. Electro-encephalograms were done at the Beth Israel-Deaconess Medical Center in Boston. This work was supported by a grant from the NutraSweet Co. to the Center for Brain Sciences and Metabolism Charitable Trust.[/quote]
Needless to say, that clearly opens up the possibility that it was biased.
Also, you say:
[quote]So, once again, if Aspartame causes headaches why aren't we seeing a massive increase in the rate of headaches? Once again you just want to trot out some tired conspiracy theories and anecdotal stories.[/quote]
Actually, migraine (persistent headaches) have become more prevalent in the last 30 years. I wouldn't know if there'even one sole cause though.
Now, I'm not saying that it's going to kill you or anything like that.
If someone likes to drink Diet Coke, that's fine by me. Just as long as he knows there's a controversial and possibly dangerous substance in it, it's his own choice. But as long as people drink it without knowing about any possible dangers, it's not their own choice. They are told it is safe when perhaps it isn't. As long as people are properly informed, and it's their free choice ONCE they are properly informed, than it's fine by me. But industry-paid-for research like that one cannot possibly be considered unbiased information.
The same goes , unfortunately nowadays, from information from the FDA.
Internet, TV, Magazines and already brainwashed people are all making us believe that aspartame its OK to drink. MONEY, DINERO, DOLLARS, THE GREEN STUFF and POWER thats what they want and they will do ANYTHING, including making people sick, in order to have what they want.
MY ADVICE: if you want to drink a soft drink, drink a REGULAR coke (it is still crap, but better than Diet Coke) better yet, drink an Organic Cola. Another ADVICE: Don't trust what the FTC, FDA and other Trade Associations have to say, there is ALOT of corruption in this country already when it comes to food and healthcare. Aspartame as well as other man made sweets might not kill you instantly, but 1000000% sure it's killing you little by little without you realizing it and without much strong symptoms for some people at first. This man made crap its not natural and its not what mother nature intended. Years from now FDA might say just like what happened with cigarrets "OPS, Aspartame its not so good for our body after all, maybe you should stop taking it" ..
People, right now softdrinks are making millions of dollars by selling their Diet coke and an ignorant person will buy it believing that it will help him/her loose or not gain weight... As long as they are making their millions, Aspartame will still be "OK" to drink and "will not cause any negative effects on you" BULL.
Diet Coke its cheaper to make than Regular Coke, so this is why its promoted very heavily through media.
Drink alot of Water or Wine and beer in moderation. If you want coke, drink Regular Coke at least it has regular sugar and not aspartame. Stay away from ALL Diet stuff because you are being tricked and deceived. These Diet products has toxins such as aspartame and many others man made ingredients, these ingredients on Diet stuff will make you FAT and cause other medical problems in the future.
Read "Aspartame is it safe?"
God Bless
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/search-handle-form/104-4216610-4171136
god bles
Food companies are clever, they brainwash you, they make you addictive to their product, they make you sick so that you go to a doctor and spend money on a drug or shot. (Food and healthcare are connected) thats why you have the FDA (FOOD and DRUG administration). and Money its the main and only reason why this is all happening
Please, does anyone have any CREDIBLE studies that show that aspartame is safe.
(I work in a research lab at Caltech -- a Nobel Laureate's lab)
The FDA - This is just an "FDA TALK PAPER" regarding a recently published scientific study (1996 at the time of this paper) that showed some link to brain tumors ---this only addresses their review process in 1981 and that rat brain tumor info was insufficiently addressed until they got further studies done in Japan (
American Dietetic Association - link gone
Centers for Disease Control - only an assessment of passively collected date on aspartame (i.e. they didn't do a study - they just collected complaints --back in '83-'84)
International Food Information Council Foundation - link gone
American Diabetes Association - only site that says it is safe: "Low calorie sweeteners are safe for everyone except people with phenylketonuria, who should not use aspartame. Calorie-free sweeteners like aspartame, saccharin, sucralose and acesulfame-K won't increase your blood glucose level." There is no study here ---they are only addressing how aspartame does not raise blood sugar levels in diabetics.
Once again --- where do I find the impartial, peer-reviewed studies that show it is safe -- I can't use any of this stuff to refute the aspartame loonies
"From: Mark Gold [mgold@shelltown.net]
Sent: Sunday, January 12, 2003 11:18 PM
To: fdadockets@oc.fda.gov
Subject: Docket # 02P-0317 Recall Aspartame as a Neurotoxic Drug: File
#9: Recent Independent Aspartame Research
Subject: Docket # 02P-0317
To: FDA Dockets Submittal
From: Mark D. Gold
Aspartame Toxicity Information Center
12 East Side Dr., Suite 2-18
Concord, NH 03301
603-225-2110
Date: January 12, 2002
Please find below Evidence File #9: Recent Independent Aspartame Research
Recent Independent Aspartame Research Results
(1998 - 2002)
The results of recent independent research continue the trend of research
not funded by the manufacturer finding serious problems with aspartame
ingestion. Details about other independent research demonstrating the
hazards of aspartame ingestion can be found in the Aspartame FAQs and
Aspartame Scientific Abuse web pages.
Table of Contents
Aspartame Ingestion Causes Formaldehyde Accumulation in the Body
Aspartame and MSG Cause to Painful Fibromyalgia Symptoms
Aspartame and Brain Tumors (Swedish Study)
Aspartame Causes Memory Loss
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Aspartame Ingestion Causes Formaldehyde Accumulation in the Body
Excerpt from:
Trocho, C., et al., 1998. "Formaldehyde Derived From Dietary Aspartame
Vinds to Tissue Components in vivo," Life Sciences, Vol. 63, No. 5, pp.
337+, 1998
"These are indeed extremely high levels for adducts of formaldehyde, a
substance responsible for chronic deleterious effects that has also been
considered carcinogenic.
....
"It is concluded that aspartame consumption may constitute a hazard
because of its contribution to the formation of formaldehyde adducts."
"It was a very interesting paper, that demonstrates that formaldehyde
formation from aspartame ingestion is very common and does indeed
accumulate within the cell, reacting with cellular proteins (mostly
enzymes) and DNA (both mitochondrial and nuclear). The fact that it
accumulates with each dose, indicates grave consequences among those who
consume diet drinks and foodstuffs on a daily basis." (Neuroscientist
Russell Blaylock, MD)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Aspartame and MSG Cause to Painful Fibromyalgia Symptoms
Ann Pharmacother 2001 Jun;35(6):702-6
Relief of fibromyalgia symptoms following discontinuation of dietary
excitotoxins.
Smith JD, Terpening CM, Schmidt SO, Gums JG. Malcolm Randall Veterans
Affairs Medical Center, Gainesville, FL, USA.
BACKGROUND: Fibromyalgia is a common rheumatologic disorder that is often
difficult to treat effectively. CASE SUMMARY: Four patients diagnosed with
fibromyalgia syndrome for two to 17 years are described. All had undergone
multiple treatment modalities with limited success. All had complete, or
nearly complete, resolution of their symptoms within months after
eliminating monosodium glutamate (MSG) or MSG plus aspartame from their
diet. All patients were women with multiple comorbidities prior to
elimination of MSG. All have had recurrence of symptoms whenever MSG is
ingested. DISCUSSION: Excitotoxins are molecules, such as MSG and
aspartate, that act as excitatory neurotransmitters, and can lead to
neurotoxicity when used in excess. We propose that these four patients may
represent a subset of fibromyalgia syndrome that is induced or exacerbated
by excitotoxins or, alternatively, may comprise an excitotoxin syndrome
that is similar to fibromyalgia. We suggest that identification of similar
patients and research with larger numbers of patients must be performed
before definitive conclusions can be made. CONCLUSIONS: The elimination of
MSG and other excitotoxins from the diets of patients with fibromyalgia
offers a benign treatment option that has the potential for dramatic
results in a subset of patients. PMID: 11408989
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Aspartame and Brain Tumors
A published study in Sweden that looked at various possible causes of
brain tumors (e.g., cell phones, aspartame) found a link between use of
diet drinks and certain types of large brain tumors in middle-aged and
elderly population groups. http://www.medscape.com/MedGenMed/braintumors
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Aspartame Causes Memory Loss
Title: DANGEROUS DIET DRINKS.
Subject(s): ASPARTAME -- Physiological effect; NONNUTRITIVE sweeteners
Side effects; MEMORY
Source: Psychology Today, Mar/Apr 2001, Vol. 34 Issue 2, p20, 2/5p
Section: [Nutrition] Facts&Findings
MIND DANGEROUS DIET DRINKS
CAN'T REMEMBER WHAT YOU HAD FOR LUNCH?
WHAT YOU ATE OR DRANK MIGHT BE THE REASON.
New research suggests that the artificial sweetener aspartame may actually
go to your head.
By Peter Rebhahn
Anecdotal evidence that aspartame disrupts memory has been growing since
the sugar substitute was approved in the early 1980s, though attempts to
prove the claim have so far been equivocal. Previous studies have tested
memory by asking aspartame users to remember lists of words or numbers--
tests of short-term memory. But according to Timothy M. Barth, Ph.D., a
psychology professor at Texas Christian University, those studies focused
on the wrong type of memory.
In his study of 90 students, Barth found that participants who regularly
drank diet sodas containing aspartame performed as well as nonusers on
laboratory tests. However, aspartame users were more likely to report
long-term memory lapses like forgetting details of personal routines or
whether or not a task had been completed.
"These people aren't crazy," says Barth. Instead, "the type of memory
problems they report are not the type of memories that have been assessed
in the typical laboratory study."
After reporting his findings at a recent Society for Neuroscience meeting,
Barth cautioned that he thinks it's premature to condemn aspartame. But he
does worry about the largely untested effects of long-term use. Already,
he has made some converts. "Several of my graduate students who drank diet
soda no longer do."
So I am still looking for the 'it's safe' studies --
A: Scientist seem to not know from one day to another if milk or water are actually good for us.
B: Im a political science major and yes money does corrupt, but you have to understand that if the risks were absolute and proven than there would be a world wide retract of the product. If there wasn't coke would be shutdown, by the government you all choose to hate so much.
C: One study will say one thing and another will say something. I know its hard for a lot of you but try and stay objective in your arguements. No one can tell me conclusivly that Diet Coke kills.
D: The arguement is actually completely ridiculus. Do you people not realize that it is common knowledge that acid for coke is shipped in hazard
waste containers. I know this and I still drink it. Tell me if I drink 12 cans a day itll cause cancer. Ill drink 11 a day
E: Jon hi and i actually found this site looking up world of warcraft. You people who attack this poor programmer need to back up, hes a programmer who drinks diet coke for gosh sakes. I see people attacking his character above here and this is ridiculous.
F: I tell ya what, why not all you coke crazy woohoo no life godda complain about something but eat prosessed to hell food hypocrits, why dont your group go see why kids are shooting other kids, or why there are people that make over 1 million dollars a year and there are people who have to make do with $3000 a year. Or better yet your group likes to bash homosexuals and their rights, lets get on that subject as well
Sorry fo my little bit of insight but jon you rock
" I thank you for that web site i have been arguing with this lady that i work with about diet coke for 2 days telling her that it can't be that bad because it is still on the market..."
Posted by Erin at 5:14 PM EST on May 17th, '01
AND
"I think that this article is absolutely 100% correct - People have this opinion about aspartame and it sucks. If they would only open 'n can of Coke Light and experience it - they will then too become firm believers that there is only one drink. I can not go through a day without it. Keep up the good work - forget about the losers - who needs them?!?!?"
Posted by CCL at 3:11 AM EST on Apr 28th, '01
What the hell kind of argument are those besides just being ignorant or addicted. Can't go a day without it? Jeez, sounds very sad. Let's get some brain juices flowing here to figure out the true answer and quit this nonsense!
Litl
So drink up Shriner.
>>I have been sick for months, I barely eat. A little bit of fruit and a light meal every couple of days.
Trouble with appetite? See a good chiropractor.
>>All I drink is diet soda. I am addicted to it...
The MSG in it is very addicting. When something is addicting the addict will say and do anything as he is in denial. See Jon's original post and you'll know what I mean.
>>...but I am so sick that I will try anything to get better.
Eliminate all MSG or glutamic acid from your diet. Drink only steam distilled water for a while. Nothing more unless it is like fruit juice from let's say a company like Odwalla which contains no MSG. Here is one of their best items though it's expensive since it is really a meal in a can. http://www.odwalla.com/product1.asp?p=beverages&s=category&id=18
Eat only U.S.D.A. certified fruits and vegetables. Nothing more.
If you must eat meat. Eat only buffalo meat which you can obtain from the web. Here is just one site of many. http://bigskybuffalo.com/
>>I also take twentysome meds a day.
See a good chiropractor to get you off those damn things. I got off of high blood pressure and cholesterol medication and will never go back.
>>I'll let you know. I am not a wacko just a sick mom that needs to get better.
Call Dr. Brian Anthony in Soquel, California for some top recommendations for a good doctor in your area. He cured me of high blood pressure and if that can be done he will help you with a doctor in your area.
w
>>...we have lawyers suing the University...
Which university?
w
Last year after reading all the I gave it up for 3 months and felt fantastic (no headaches, no depression, no mood swings, no aches and clicks in the mornings, able to focus and concentrate).
So what happened ... well people I am back but will not be a diet coke drinker from tomorrow !! IT IS A DRUG, when I smoked it was the same, you give up and go back because your body craves it, your brain tells you you enjoy it ... but the fact is your body craves the toxins.
The only difference is not everyone hated the diet coke experience the first time you tried it, unlike smokers (who all choked with disgust ... but somehow still carried on) diet coke drinkers tend to enjoy the experience, that makes it harder to give up.
When I gave up, I had over a week of severe migrains, fell down the stairs with a one of the many bad stomach cramps, could not focus at work or home and a whole load of other drawbacks, all as a result of giving up the drink I LOVE !!
I want to raise a challenge, everyone reading this ... GIVE IT UP FOR 1 MONTH ... see how different you feel and report back honestly
what have you got to loose ?
Your research is fantastic! ;D My grandmother and I drink a lot of Diet Coke, and it has not caused problems. I did not believe the stuff people tossed at me.
I've heard both sides about it being dangerous, but not really knowing the details strongly of either argument i'm not in a position to argue it.
Doug Elsley, what you describe sounds like the symptoms of a caffiene addiction to me. I avoid drinking softdrink at all (cept as a mixer with alcs) purely for health reasons. It's highly acidic and carbornated which doesn't help much either.
What to say?
Ive got it
Coke a Cola symbol of free west.
so just how much are you being paid?
i have a masters degree in biochemistry and i would not go anywhere near the stuff. i advise you do the same.
REading this page does have me worried though because I got a bad liver report from my doctor and I don't drink alcohol. So now I'm wondering if I haven't damaged my liver with this stuff. What to do, what to do. Perhaps I should switch to something safe, like water. My local municipality adds flouride to the water and that causes cancer. Wine and beer cause more liver damage. Milk apparantly has antibiotics and growth hormones in it. Hell, maybe I'll just get it over with and die from dehydration.
I worked for a very famous doctor in Boca Raton Fl.- we had people from all over the country with lots of incurable ailments( horrible joint pains, unable to suddenly walk,slurry speech, face paralysis,etc.)
First question Dr. asked?? Do you drink diet coke/aspartame?
Interestingly all the incurables were all heavy and long time users of aspartame. The doctor sent them home with order to stop for one month. Guess what happened? All these people who spent so much $$ on previous tests,doctors,and medicines were all of the sudden magically cured after one month.
I witnessed this with my own eyes- I don't care what the FDA or anyone says--there is something terribly wrong with our country that still sells this poison to its people.
By the way-I am not a wacko lunatic,I haven't read any literature for or against diet coke/aspartame. I have just seen about 60 diff.devastating illnesses cured by simply going cold turkey.
So how is this possible??
My conclusion is there must be lots of very rich people getting richer while we all stay hooked and getting sicker. Staying sick from all the foods and drinks with Aspartame is making a ton of money. Jon-you must be one of these people- or maybe you just enjoy all the controversy from your own website.
- ordinary medical assistant from FL.--
Guess what i just read that it actually make you want to eat more carbohydrate. It is so true i noticed when i go to the restaurant im thinking to myself no carbohydrate.....only chicken salad. then after i get the diet coke , i just want to eat something like filled with carbohydrates.
Explain that.......
i drink normal coke purely for the reason that i prefer the taste, i have done a blind fold test with diet coke and normal coke and i could tell the difference, i could taste the difference between the natural sugar sweetness in normal coke and the chemical sweetness in the diet.
anyway on to the conspiracy bit
i dont know mch and havent done much research so if you could tell me more, that would be great.
what i know (what i have read) about aspartame is that it gets absorbed into your tissue instead of passing through the body, which if its correct sounds scary.
and that donald rumsfeld or dick chainy i cant remember, its one of those big U.S government prople anyway, owns most of nutrisweet and helped pass through the law making it leagal. if anyone has more info on this let me know
thanks
I am amazed at what an emotional issue this is for people, particularly people addicted to caffiene, which is well documented to make you miserable when you try to kick it. So unfortunately, like smokers who rationalise their decision to smoke every time they light up, your supporters judgement is skewed by the other chemical they can't live without in Diet Coke. Having said that I have no idea how harmful or otherwise aspartame is, but I don't believe for one second the studies are long term enough to be conclusive, surely the onus is on those licensing the product to prove it safe? And as for the government swooping in to rescue us all were aspartame found to be damaging to your health, I wouldn't hold your breath. Cigarretes can still be purchased legally under the ridiculous rationale that consumers can now make an "informed choice" about a highly addictive product. And would this be the same government that sends its troops into battle (which is unhealthy, I get that) with radioactive material in their munitions?
Or, perhaps there is a job in this for someone? Any researchers out there? There are most likely enough people, like myself, who could be studied for the long term effects? Just a thought.
I don't like aspartame because it tastes the same as sticking your tongue to frozen metal. It's not really a pleasant flavour.
besides, soda pop is bad for your teeth whether its diet or not. It's just crap. You're better off drinking water. mmmm tasty shire water.
LOL
http://www.lightparty.com/Health/DietCokeAspartame.html
It's not crazy to be suspicious of a chemical company with as ugly of a track record as theirs. Looking at their ties to politicians, I believe it's also reasonable to suspect possible foul play.
You have to consider the amount of money at stake here. People have killed for a lot less.
Obviously we can't know for certain, but to merely rule out the evidence pointing to concerns is rather ignorant.
An interesting citation in Wikipedia reads as follows:
"In Survey of Aspartame studies: correlation of outcome and funding sources, Ralph G. Walton surveyed 166 studies of aspartame in peer reviewed medical literature. 74 studies had Nutrasweet industry related funding and 92 were independently funded. 100% of the industry funded research attested to aspartame's safety, whereas 92% of the independently funded research identified a problem."
I've read that unlike natural sources of methanol such as fruit, aspartame does not metabolize the methanol neutralizing ethanol. This is one possible reason why comparing Diet soda to tomatos seems somewhat skewed.
Aspartame is brought to us by the same people who brought us agent orange, 2,4,5-T, bovine growth hormone, myriad genetically modified produce and livestock, and Round Up(tm). It is the result of a synthetic chemical reaction.
I certainly don't want them putting anything in my body without full transparent disclosure and extensive independent review.
http://www.myaspartameexperiment.com/
Results were pretty shocking. I suppose the subjects could have developed such horrible accelerated cancer from other incidental sources, but the experiment seemed pretty sound.
So when you say in your posts things like, "All studies have come back with no negative results" (paraphrasing), it just shows how biased your statements are.
I don't pretend to know the definitive answer... I just suspect there's more to it than those who are cashing in on it are willing to tell you.
You are acting very irresponsibly by making the claims you make.
Oh yeah, did you know that Coca Cola used to contain COCAINE? Guess that's harmless too...
Your conviction is admirable, but your cause is not.
Cheers.
Thanks,Mike
www.dietdrinkaddiction.com
* No control over how much water a rat could drink, so therefore no control over how much aspartame was ingested.
* No control over amount of food ingested. Could the sweetened water have changed the diet of the test subjects? No information.
* No double-blind anywhere. How were the test subjects selected?
* No information on lifetime. If these rats really were suffering from cancer and not other diseases, shouldn't it have shortened their lives?
I'm not saying the results were acceptable. On the contrary, with no real controls and measures in place, who knows what torture the rats went through?
Last I heard, the population segment with the largest increase in brain tumors over the last 30 years is the population that uses the LEAST aspartame. How curious.
Regarding the rat studies, they had tumor studies for saccharin as well as Aspartame, both of which were clearly not conclusive enough to have either product pulled from the market. I stopped putting any personal faith in rodent studies after I had a series of pet mice and then a rat, all of which lived no more than 24 months and all of which grew massive tumors before they died. None of them were Diet Coke drinkers.
Regarding brain tumors specifically, I've decided to let the Diet Coke and my cell phone race to see which one can kill me first, assuming, of course, that I don't get killed first by any of the following: man offering perfume samples at gas station, man with one hook for a hand on a deserted stretch of highway, too much sun, not enough sun, overcooked bacon, or a brown recluse spider hiding under the toilet seat of a public restroom.
To add your comment, click here.
|











