The common good

by Jon Sullivan - 2022-11-10 - Jonism

<<<<< previous blog         next blog >>>>>        album containing this post's photo

I feel that it is a mistake to separate what is good for me from what is good for humanity. But I've yet to find balance in that ideal.

The Stoics believe that the most important thing is to live in harmony with nature. And by "nature" they mean all that is and ever was. Not just the universe, but also the thing that creates the universe - The math and logic and science that all matter and time arises from. And they believe we must be in such harmony because we are one with the universe, and thus nature, and thus all humanity.

Yes, we can mentally see ourselves as individuals, apart from everything, independent and individual. Alone with our hopes and fears and desires. But we aren't alone really. Everything we know came from someone else. Teachers, authors, parents, friends, coworkers. We can enshrine individual thought and expression, but even our most selfish thoughts are colored by the information others filtered before we go to it. Filtered by the actions and opinions of our friends and family. By the community we live in and the neighbors we must share it with. We can't separate ourselves from physics. Even if we are spiritual, we are still flesh. We can only be truly independent if we limit our perception and filter out more and more of the external. It would be nice to imagine some wise person coming up with a huge system of knowledge by their own intellect alone. But it was never that way. Science, art, religion, culture, philosophy, are all the product of incremental additions to previous work.

We can follow it back through history and through evolution and through astrophysics until we are left to conclude we are just star stuff, and eventually we'll return to star stuff. Making us one with the stars, one with nature, one with everyone who shares that nature.

Said another way.... We can fetishize our independence. We can insist we are special and more deserving than others. We can put ourselves and our team first. But only if we reject that we are one with humanity. Only if we assume our closed world is best and anything "other" is inferior. We are only an island, only truly a hermit, when we deny all the things that make that island possible.

I choose to believe that we are just brief physical collections of atoms moving through time, gaining some atoms as we go, leaving some behind. And that we, and all living things, evolve to maximize our ecological niche. As humans, that niche is to be the best rational social creatures we can be. And I choose to reject the notion that we are naturally divided into winners and losers who must fight for food and shelter and sex. I choose to believe that each of us are the best we can be when we live in harmony. Sharing rather than hoarding. Enjoying together rather than coveting alone. Accepting and fostering the happiness in others, as they foster the happy in us. Refusing to make winning depend on others suffering. I choose to believe that we're beyond "survival of the fittest".

It's a happy idea. We can all live together and be happy just by recognizing our commonality. But..... It's hard to practice when harmony is so hard to find. In 2022 America we only find harmony in the small subset of people who have the same opinions we do. We've built a version of humanity that rejects the bounty we could share, denies the ability for our vast wealth to help everyone together. It was easy for Marcus Aurelius to spend so much time focusing on the common good. He literally controlled both the resources and their distribution. While I find myself hated by many fellow Americans just for thinking wealth is bad and sharing is good. As much as I love Jesus stuff, I'll always be hated for putting my faith in helping those who have less.

What is harmony for me then? Where is the harmony I should act on when so much of humanity seems selfish and predatory? How do I turn an idea of acting for the common good into practice when so many are motivated only by greed and victory? Is true harmony even real?

<<<<< previous blog         next blog >>>>>
Diane Diggins
2022-11-10 12:26:35 : Why don't you go pack groceries at one of the local food banks there in Eugene for a couple of hours each week? That would be a very practical, useful way to help other who have less, and nobody there would hate you.

Jon Sullivan
2022-11-10 14:39:54 : Volunteerism is a practice I've thought about quite a bit over the years. And while it certainly is a way to take action towards the common good, I don't think I'm really comfortable doing it. I hope people don't misunderstand my fixation on "virtue" lately. I'm not trying to be a good person, just trying to live my best life. I believe virtue brings me in harmony with the universe. But I'll never be the sort of person who volunteers for community service. I tend to throw money at the problem rather than get involved. I'm sure some will see this as laziness or hypocrisy. If it is, I'll live with that label. I don't see capital V Virtue as a call to action, but more as a bounding box on actions and reactions.

My post today was more about trying to live in harmony with a nation determined to stamp it out. What does harmony mean when the "common good" is seen as Communism?

Diane Diggins
2022-11-11 13:03:07 : We talked about volunteerism several years ago, and you did say then that it was something you weren't comfortable with. But you've also been talking lately about getting outside of your comfort zone to explore other experiences. I don't really see volunteerism as being virtuous, just as having fun with like minded people.

I'm sorry I don't understand your last paragraph, especially the last sentence, but sometimes I'm just a bit dense I guess.

Diane Diggins
2022-11-11 13:03:12 : We talked about volunteerism several years ago, and you did say then that it was something you weren't comfortable with. But you've also been talking lately about getting outside of your comfort zone to explore other experiences. I don't really see volunteerism as being virtuous, just as having fun with like minded people.

I'm sorry I don't understand your last paragraph, especially the last sentence, but sometimes I'm just a bit dense I guess.

Diane Diggins
2022-11-11 13:13:52 : Sorry about the double post. My ancient lap top does weird stuff sometimes. I can't figure out a way to delete the second one to get the mess off your page.

Sign-In With Google To Leave a Comment:
<<<<< previous blog         next blog >>>>>
News
Eugene weather
39.7 degrees F, Clouds (broken clouds)
Min: 38.01 ,Max: 41.38 ,Humidity: 92, Wind: 6.91
Eugene, OR - Best Restaurants
Eugene, OR - Things to do
Eugene, OR - Fish reports
Oregon road conditions
Recent Posts
- Stoicism vs Epicureanism
    Should happiness be the result, or should it be the goal?
- Thanksgiving 2022
    Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday. This year was perhaps my favorite Thanksgiving.
- Introspection
    I'm settled in in Oregon now. Most of the chaos is past. Let's look around and see where we are.
- Snippets
    As I settle in and kick back to think about this new life, I'm slowly figuring out how deep this all goes.
- Jon is rich
    One of my currencies, how I measure my value, is how many great photos I'm taking.
- Jon is a weirdo
    I keep thinking about how I've changed over the last three years. Let's break it down and put it to rest.
- Shambles
    New Jon is weird. Old Jon was weird. Life in Oregon is weird. It's weird all the way down.
Food I Cooked
Old School Blogroll
kottke.org
Home of fine hypertext products.
MetaFilter
A community weblog.
A Chicken Is Not Pillage
You forgot his exclamation point! It defines him. He put it there for a reason, to show how in! your! face! he is.
jessamyn.com
abada abada - twenty years of jessamyn
Matt Haughey
A Whole Lotta Nothing
dooce
Heater, Mother Of Lance
Anil Dash
A blog about making culture. Since 1999.
Some Bits
Nelson's weblog
Everlasting Blort
proud member of the reality-based community
Whatever
This machine mocks fascists
Scripting News
It's even worse than it appears.
Flutterby
Short attention spans in a world full of flowers
mimi smartypants
Seriously, though: what's with the penguins?
Montreal City Weblog
Stupid Evil Bastard
What the fuck is wrong with you people?
Idle Words
brevity is for the weak
Making Light
Say what you mean. Bear witness. Iterate.
wilwheaton.net
50,000 Monkeys at 50,000 Typewriters Can't Be Wrong
Justin Hall
Growing & breaking down since 1994
Mike the Mad Biologist
Helping idiots who desperately need my assistance by calling them fucking morons since 2004
jwz
MSSV
AKMA’s Random Thoughts
Ruminations about hermeneutics, theology, theory, politics, ecclesiastical life… and exercise.
things magazine
An occasional weblog about objects, collections and discoveries
Miscellaneous Heathen
Hold to the now, the here, through which all future plunges to the past.
kimberussell.com
where it's always Virgo Season
Cockeyed
Recent Trips
Getting it ready for you.