Chicken marsala stuffed mushrooms recipe

by Jon Sullivan - 2019-10-08 - Food

<<<<< previous blog         next blog >>>>>

I love the idea of using scooped out mushrooms as a bowl filled with various things for appetizers.

I remember first discovering chicken marsala in an Italian restaurant I waited tables in during college. The recipes there were mainly from the owners mother. Perhaps more New York Italian, but I don't know for sure. What I do know is that it was delicious and deeply satisfying. For me it's a favorite comfort food. Chicken and mushrooms are obviously a great combination. Marsala wine is wonderfully unique and sweet. The umami flavors from the mushrooms and tomato paste are wonderful. And as a bonus it's super simple and quick.

This version isn't classic chicken marsala, but it's still a great looking appetizer. Note that for the version in the photo I used the wrong cheese. Just ignore that. I'll swap the photos out the next time I cook it. Smoked gouda was an awesome idea in my brain, not so much in reality.

I suppose you could use big portobellos for this rather than regular button mushrooms, but I've never tried that. I like the idea of smaller app sized portions. The amounts below are for 6 mushrooms, I usually cook for 1-2. So be sure to scale that up if you're doing a big party.

This recipe works great with leftover chicken or turkey. If you go that route, add the chicken at the same time as listed, but obviously you don't need to cook it, so just heat it through.

  • Heat the marsala in a medium high pan to reduce to 1/3. Pour that into a bowl, whisk in the flour until it's dissolved, and set aside.

  • Preheat oven to 375.

  • You need to precook the mushroom "bowls" a bit, as the final step is just to melt the cheese. Scoop out the stem and center to form a bowl. Reserve everything you scoop out for the next step. Don't scoop away too much of the sides or bottom or your bowl will collapse. Brush the entire mushroom with olive oil and cook on a foil lined pan for 5-7 minutes. Keep an eye on them and take out if look like they are cooking too fast. You don't want them to lose structural integrity, and they will cook a wee bit more after you take them out. Set them aside when done.

  • Chop the reserved mushroom bits. Melt 1 tsp butter in a pan. Add the chopped mushrooms and leave them alone while they brown.

  • After the mushrooms are browned, add another 1 tsp butter, the chicken, and cook through.

  • Add the shallot, capper, garlic, tomato paste, and oregano. Mix well and cook until the shallots are translucent. Add salt and pepper to taste.

  • Re-whisk the reduced marsala and flour, and pour that into the pan with everything else. Mix constantly as it thickens.

  • Add the lemon juice, mix well, and taste. You may need to add more lemon, but it's a careful balance. You need enough acid to balance the sweetness, but not so much the lemon overpowers. Go slow and add more if needed.

  • Spoon the chicken mixture into each mushroom and try to mound it up a bit. Place the sliced mozzarella on top. You can break it up if needed. You may have extra chicken mixture, just eat it when no one is looking.

  • Place the mushrooms under a broiler and cook until the cheese is melted and slightly browned. These look like you should pick them up with fingers and eat. But they will be crazy hot inside. So I suggest a knife and fork.

    1 cup marsala
    1 tsp flour
    6 large regular mushrooms
    olive oil
    2 tbsp butter
    1 cup chicken cubed, small
    2 tbsp minced shallot
    1/2 tsp minced caper
    1 minced garlic clove
    1 tsp tomato paste
    2 tsp minced fresh oregano
    1 tsp lemon juice
    thinly sliced mozzarella

    Buy prints

    <<<<< previous blog         next blog >>>>>
    2019-10-09 06:29:52 : I do still think about the chicken marsala sandwich at Zimorinos. That was yummy. And Italian nachos. Mmmmmmm....

    2019-10-09 06:30:54 : Caper? Really?

    Jon Sullivan
    2019-10-09 06:42:10 : Zim's chicken marsala sandwich was delicious. The Italian nachos just make me remember, "It's really hot. I warned you." And you can leave the caper out if they don't have them in Kalispell.

    Sign-In With Google To Leave a Comment:
    <<<<< previous blog         next blog >>>>>
  • News
    Eugene weather
    33.51 degrees F, Rain (moderate rain)
    Min: 32.25 ,Max: 36.36 ,Humidity: 95, Wind: 12.66
    Eugene, OR - Best Restaurants
    Eugene, OR - Things to do
    Eugene, OR - Fish reports
    Oregon road conditions
    Recent Posts
    - Throwdown
        Moving to Oregon = Go all the places, take all the photos, eat all the food. I didn't realize I'd be cooking most of it myself.
    - The in-between
        I've been all about chasing joy and living my best life. Have I found it? Somewhere between crazy/joyous and sane/dreary?
    - Mustard recipe
        PNW is a block of ice. Leaving the apartment might mean death. So, as one does, I made mustard.
    - Jon is gassy
        Day 6 of Covid. All symptoms have been replaced by excessive flatulence. My fart cloud and I will continue to self isolate.
    - Jon is bland
        A scary thought : What if I get long term Covid loss of smell/taste? If I can't taste food, then who the hell am I?
    - Well f**k....
        I dodged Covid for a long time. But I knew, sooner or later. We'll all get it sooner or later.
    - Best photos 2023
        I judge the success of my life by the best photos I take each year. In 2023 life was good.
    Food I Cooked
    Old School Blogroll
    Home of fine hypertext products.
    A community weblog.
    A Chicken Is Not Pillage
    You forgot his exclamation point! It defines him. He put it there for a reason, to show how in! your! face! he is.
    abada abada - twenty years of jessamyn
    Matt Haughey
    A Whole Lotta Nothing
    Heater, Mother Of Lance
    Anil Dash
    A blog about making culture. Since 1999.
    Some Bits
    Nelson's weblog
    Everlasting Blort
    proud member of the reality-based community
    This machine mocks fascists
    Scripting News
    It's even worse than it appears.
    Short attention spans in a world full of flowers
    mimi smartypants
    Seriously, though: what's with the penguins?
    Montreal City Weblog
    Stupid Evil Bastard
    What the fuck is wrong with you people?
    Idle Words
    brevity is for the weak
    Making Light
    Say what you mean. Bear witness. Iterate.
    50,000 Monkeys at 50,000 Typewriters Can't Be Wrong
    Justin Hall
    Growing & breaking down since 1994
    Mike the Mad Biologist
    Helping idiots who desperately need my assistance by calling them fucking morons since 2004
    AKMA’s Random Thoughts
    Ruminations about hermeneutics, theology, theory, politics, ecclesiastical life… and exercise.
    things magazine
    An occasional weblog about objects, collections and discoveries
    Miscellaneous Heathen
    Hold to the now, the here, through which all future plunges to the past.
    where it's always Virgo Season
    Recent Trips
    Getting it ready for you.